consider me Gura Geared
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
ssan nice pics. I said that it is tricky, not impossible. And I mentioned that I was talking about the sky, not the reflections.. Plus I was talking about below 17mm situations, as in 14-17mm.
One can't really be bothered with blanket statements like that no matter who it comes from. I use a CPL on the ultra-wide angles (10-22 & 16-35L) all the time. Tell me if you see anything wrong with the sky:
I would actually argue that you can make generalizations. That CPL's are problematic with ultra wide angle lenses is one I would agree with, even if there are exceptions. Everyone's tolerance is different but I would have probably dodged the dark band above the building in the first image. The CPL banding isn't bad but it's there. The skies in the second and fourth images don't work for me at all. To be clear, I'm not arguing that these are bad images or that there aren't benefits to your using a CPL for these shots; I'm saying that the generalization holds true.