Since I don't know what you mean by all around shooting I'll make a few broader comments. First, slow FF zooms (constant f4) seem an odd choice on aps-c to me - you're usually paying more for a ff lens, you're using only part of its glass, it doesn't perform as well as it would on a FF body and may not perform as well as some aps-c lenses on an aps-c body anyway, and, if you care about noise and like shallow focus, starting at f4 seems rather limiting. Second, how will you be viewing your photos? Zooms aren't as good as primes, usually, but if you're not using a big monitor or regularly viewing at 100% or printing big, the difference will matter less, if at all; the very good Canon 10-18 and the surprisingly good Sigma 18-250 - both have IS - may well be good enough for just about anything. (I'm evidently part of a tiny minority -of one? - in being quite underwhelmed by the 17-55 2.8, whose price seems to me way out of proportion to its image quality.)
I tend to prefer primes, many of which have IS (I could probably go all day with just the 35mm IS, while perhaps wishing it were faster still), but I'm not you ....