To each it's own ...
I feel each photo conveys a different sense of "focus" on the subject. If you want to show the person, then no doubt the first photo will be used. A focus of the moon with some background, then, the second. And there is a recognizable figure of a person --- a woman, in the foreground. Just no telling what the big clump is next to the woman. Not bad having both together, giving the viewer a couple of stories.
I like both.