Critics corner?

Who would like a critique corner thread or area?

  • Just no.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    16
  • Poll closed .

Valvebounce

CR Pro
Apr 3, 2013
4,555
450
57
Isle of Wight
Following a post on the bird thread I am prompted to suggest this.
A copy of the other response is below.

Hi Alan.
Quote from Alan, “it’s always good to receive constructive criticism, and there is not enough of it here.”

Quite a while ago I was thinking of suggesting a ‘critics corner,” I started on a set of rules for my proposal, my thought was that initially it would probably be one open thread, all subjects allowed and included.

Critique Corner.
Rules.
Please post here if you really would like constructive criticism.

Don’t post here if all you want is praise.
Don’t post here if you don’t like or want criticism.

“I think this picture is rubbish” and “nice shot” are not sufficient, replies should include the reason why you do or do not like the photo, composition, lighting etc are good reasons to criticise a shot, I don’t like cats or Cadillacs are not good reasons to criticise a shot.


What do you think, worth asking for?

Cheers, Graham.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

AlanF

Desperately seeking birds
CR Pro
Aug 16, 2012
12,356
22,534
Yes, I did ask for it. I first started posting bird pictures on a Dutch site that was moderated. If you want an honest and direct criticism ask a Dutchman and you will get it! Most of my images were rejected by the mods, and the forum members made lots of comments. It was the best photographic education I had ever received and worth all the bruises. I'd be more than happy to continue my education, but maybe it should be done in the specialist threads? And gentle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Upvote 0
Yes, I did ask for it. I first started posting bird pictures on a Dutch site that was moderated. If you want an honest and direct criticism ask a Dutchman and you will get it! Most of my images were rejected by the mods, and the forum members made lots of comments. It was the best photographic education I had ever received and worth all the bruises. I'd be more than happy to continue my education, but maybe it should be done in the specialist threads? And gentle.
... and there is me thinking comments I made were formulated so circumspect ...
W.
 
Upvote 0

Maximilian

The dark side - I've been there
CR Pro
Nov 7, 2013
5,666
8,492
Germany
Hi Graham!

I welcome your idea and thank you for your initial thoughts.
Some additions that come to my mind (not always well worded, apologies):

Replies and critique should be polite, constructive and thoughtful. (some of this is already included in the general forum rules, but...)
Constructive discussion about different opinions is welcome. Excuses and defensiveness don't help the discussion as well as the learning effect.

Just my two cents.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Upvote 0

Maximilian

The dark side - I've been there
CR Pro
Nov 7, 2013
5,666
8,492
Germany
… to continue my education, but maybe it should be done in the specialist threads? And gentle.
Hi Alan!

Sorry, but I don't understand that. I suppose it gets lost in translation in my mind.
Whom or what do you think about when you say "specialist threads"?

Thanks in advance to specify this for me.
 
Upvote 0

AlanF

Desperately seeking birds
CR Pro
Aug 16, 2012
12,356
22,534
Hi Alan!

Sorry, but I don't understand that. I suppose it gets lost in translation in my mind.
Whom or what do you think about when you say "specialist threads"?

Thanks in advance to specify this for me.
Birds in the Bird thread, Black and White in the B&W threads, Landscapes in the Landscapes threads etc.
 
Upvote 0

Valvebounce

CR Pro
Apr 3, 2013
4,555
450
57
Isle of Wight
Hi Alan.
Unfortunately it seems that no one in the normal threads knows whether they should critique or not, some don’t take kindly to uninvited criticism, it seems a dedicated area would mean not having to ask for criticism each time nor having to apologise for giving unsolicited critique, if you post in critique corner you better be ready for criticism!
Sometimes we just want to post a photo that we already know is not top notch but has some interest without having to explain ourselves!
I imagine initially it would be a thread, later it might be popular enough to become a header and sub threads!

Cheers, Graham.

Birds in the Bird thread, Black and White in the B&W threads, Landscapes in the Landscapes threads etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Upvote 0

Valvebounce

CR Pro
Apr 3, 2013
4,555
450
57
Isle of Wight
Hi takesome1.
I get your point, but the picture threads have a great community spirit and hopefully that would transfer to a critique situation, anyone not playing nice would most likely get burnt, plus many of the people that post shots here do excel in their craft!
Yes there will always be the occasional tit but there is always the ignore button!
Hopefully a critique corner will require no more moderation than the rest of the forum.
Personally I don’t find great shot Graham too helpful, it gives one a false sense of accomplishment, “nice shot but cropping it here would look better” or “raise the exposure a bit and.....” can be much more help for the future!

Cheers, Graham.

Asking for constructive criticism from those that excel in their craft is a great idea.
Asking for constructive criticism from the general public in an internet forum is just self abuse.
 
Upvote 0

AlanF

Desperately seeking birds
CR Pro
Aug 16, 2012
12,356
22,534
Hi takesome1.
I get your point, but the picture threads have a great community spirit and hopefully that would transfer to a critique situation, anyone not playing nice would most likely get burnt, plus many of the people that post shots here do excel in their craft!
Yes there will always be the occasional tit but there is always the ignore button!
Hopefully a critique corner will require no more moderation than the rest of the forum.
Personally I don’t find great shot Graham too helpful, it gives one a false sense of accomplishment, “nice shot but cropping it here would look better” or “raise the exposure a bit and.....” can be much more help for the future!

Cheers, Graham.
You are absolutely right. The argumentative ones are rarely found displaying their images.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 2 users
Upvote 0

Ozarker

Love, joy, and peace to all of good will.
CR Pro
Jan 28, 2015
5,933
4,336
The Ozarks
Hi takesome1.
I get your point, but the picture threads have a great community spirit and hopefully that would transfer to a critique situation, anyone not playing nice would most likely get burnt, plus many of the people that post shots here do excel in their craft!
Yes there will always be the occasional tit but there is always the ignore button!
Hopefully a critique corner will require no more moderation than the rest of the forum.
Personally I don’t find great shot Graham too helpful, it gives one a false sense of accomplishment, “nice shot but cropping it here would look better” or “raise the exposure a bit and.....” can be much more help for the future!

Cheers, Graham.
I think the picture threads have a great community spirit because people tend to not criticize. It is the one place to go, post a photo, and almost nobody says a word on the negative side. I know from experience from such threads that some people just get jealous or pissed at others because they can't do what the other person does no matter how hard they try. They use that bad feeling to rip others apart. I think people can ask for criticism if they want it in the threads that already exist.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Upvote 0

YuengLinger

Print the ones you love.
CR Pro
Dec 20, 2012
3,751
2,269
USA
Asking for constructive criticism from those that excel in their craft is a great idea.
Asking for constructive criticism from the general public in an internet forum is just self abuse.
From what I understand, "self-abuse" is the bread and butter of the internet.
 
Upvote 0