Colour help...please!

Ewinter

EOS RP
Aug 21, 2012
223
0
So, this might be me being stupid, and may be in the wrong part of the site (didn't know where to put it)
I've recently gone up to the 5dMkIII but had the same issues with the 7D and the 450D.
I can't get the colour the way that is pleasing to me. I love shooting black and white, and the more contrast, the better. I also like punchy colours, but can never get skin tones to look just right to me. I know the trick about lifting red, orange and yellow luminance to stop it crunching the skin tones while bumping contrast.

Attached are two versions of the same image, this is the most to my liking I can get the colour. I almost like the black and white, apart from some composition things.

Can anyone help me here please? I can see other people's work where the skin tones appear perfect. Do I need a better diffuser? Or is the image fine?
Many thanks for any replies
Elliot
 

Attachments

  • wp-4307-2.jpg
    wp-4307-2.jpg
    385.4 KB · Views: 836
  • wp-4307.jpg
    wp-4307.jpg
    552.1 KB · Views: 892

Ewinter

EOS RP
Aug 21, 2012
223
0
I'm using LR4, sRGB all through my workflow and a calibrated P-iPS monitor in a 5500k environment. I think there's too much red in the skin tone... maybe a tiny bit of selective desaturation would help...and a crop
 

Attachments

  • wp-4307-2.jpg
    wp-4307-2.jpg
    539.6 KB · Views: 831

Mt Spokane Photography

I post too Much on Here!!
CR Pro
Mar 25, 2011
16,619
1,577
It looks pretty heavily saturated. rather than increasing saturation, back it off and use the vibrance control. vibrance increases saturation but not for skin tones.

You could selectively work on the reds as well.

Also try some of the camera calibration profiles. Camera Neutral will desaturate the skin tones.
 

Ewinter

EOS RP
Aug 21, 2012
223
0
I do work on the reds and use the vibrancy instead of saturation-i'll try the neutral, thanks
 

Harry Muff

EOS RP
Aug 29, 2011
412
0
Toronto
www.flickr.com
For those concerned about accurate colours, I would recommend taking a look at the the Colorchecker Passport from X-Rite. Not cheap but the difference in all the colours is surprising.
 

nightbreath

EOS RP
Aug 30, 2011
454
0
34
Ukraine
luxuryphoto.com.ua
Nothing comes for free. Just keep trying and you'll get the color you want with experience :)
Why did you do her so neutral? If she's under sunlight, shouldn't there be sunlight cast? (Think about it) ;)
 

Trevor

EOS M50
Jan 11, 2012
27
0
www.trevorsmeaton.com
Ewinter said:
So, this might be me being stupid, and may be in the wrong part of the site (didn't know where to put it)
I've recently gone up to the 5dMkIII but had the same issues with the 7D and the 450D.
I can't get the colour the way that is pleasing to me. I love shooting black and white, and the more contrast, the better. I also like punchy colours, but can never get skin tones to look just right to me. I know the trick about lifting red, orange and yellow luminance to stop it crunching the skin tones while bumping contrast.

Attached are two versions of the same image, this is the most to my liking I can get the colour. I almost like the black and white, apart from some composition things.

Can anyone help me here please? I can see other people's work where the skin tones appear perfect. Do I need a better diffuser? Or is the image fine?
Many thanks for any replies
Elliot


There is no ISO standard for skin tones ... it is a matter of taste...
I just looked at your website - lots of right looking skin tones to me.

In the image you've shown here, there are very large areas of light tone (her clothing and the building) ... I think these have an effect on how her skin looks...
 

agierke

EOS RP
Feb 23, 2012
438
0
44
Delaware
it looks as though you at least popped a bit of flash into the scene (bit of a catchlight in the heel of her shoe). was there another strobe source lighting her?

the reason i ask is that you can gel flashes/strobes with a straw colored gel to get better/healthier looking skin tones. she does look rather pink in the first shot but there is a bit of coolness to her skin tone that could use some warming up. fair skinned people often shoot like this and benefit greatly from a straw colored gel.

the 2nd shot she starts to look washed out. any chance you can link to some photos that you find the color pleasing so we have a better frame of reference?

nice shot regardless though. and your b&w interpretation is nice.
 
<-- start Taboola -->