Price point of a 5Dmk2 replacement

[mreco99]

Obviously we dont know what the spec is of a 5Dmk2 replacement (even if one ever appears) but there was lots of 'talk' about product realignment in previous posts, and a guess at new range entry costs.

All of you waiting for a 5DMK2 replacement, if it WAS $3500 would you still get it?

I for one wouldnt, thats just too expensive, so THEN i would be getting the 5DMK2.... QUICKLY lol before they dissapeared.
I think i might just give up photography for 6 months, come back later when its all over.

 

[UncleFester]

$3500 is too much for only incremental improvements. I'd start looking into the M9 or mf film even.

 

[Loswr]

All of you waiting for a 5DMK2 replacement, if it WAS $3500 would you still get it?

Possibly...if it had a substantially improved AF system and a faster frame rate. Unless I'd already bought a 1DsIV, that is.

Will we see a 5DIII that's more expensive than the 5DII? I'd say, almost certianly. Granted, the 5DII was released at a significantly lower price than the original 5D. But during the three years separating the 5D and 5DII, the ¥/$ exchange rate was relatively flat. Since 2008, the yen has gained a lot on the dollar, hitting an all-time high earlier this year. That's partly behind the recent spate of increased lens prices, and I'd expect those increases to be mirrored in a 5DII replacement. $3500? Probably not. But I can certainly see a $2999 price tag for body-only.

 

[TexPhoto]

$2500 was a huge chunk of money for me when I bought my 5DII, paying any more would be difficult. That said, my guess for the price is $3200, body only.

 

[Meh]

All of you waiting for a 5DMK2 replacement, if it WAS $3500 would you still get it?

Yes if it's sufficiently better than the 5D2 but that may not turn out to be the case. Regardless, I doubt it will be priced above the list price of 5D2 which is $2700 I think.

 

[Mt Spokane Photography]

Camera prices have been falliing, but lens prices go up. Polaroid sold low priced cameras and high priced high profit film. Printer makers sell printers at or below cost and high priced toner / ink.

Expect the same price. Canon wants you to buy a FF camera and then you'll want a "L" lens to go with it. --- Gotcha ;D

 

[Loswr]

Expect the same price. Canon wants you to buy a FF camera and then you'll want a "L" lens to go with it. --- Gotcha ;D

They've already 'got' me, with 9 L-series lenses in the kit. But if a 1DsIV comes out at the same price as the 1DsIII, I'll be a happy fellow...

 

[ecka]

$2999.98 8)
IMHO, they will try to convince us that it's reasonably priced or even "cheap" ... 5D3 for less than $3000 ;D
I'm sure there are people who would pay much much more if they could get it right now (an engineering sample), just to be first.

 

[sb]

I paid $3500 for 5DMk2 when it came out here in Canada in 2008 cause Canadian dollar was crap. So I'm mentally already prepared to spend the same on Mk3 Absolutely no regrets. That camera is the best thing since sliced bread, and now that it's $1999 I may get another one as backup.

 

[unfocused]

All of you waiting for a 5DMK2 replacement, if it WAS $3500 would you still get it?

Absolutely not. But, I don't have to earn a living with my camera. And, I'm not waiting for a 5D III anyway. My 7D does everything I want and more. Compromises? Sure...but that's life.

Frankly, I think anyone who spends $3,000 on a camera body and isn't using it to earn a living ought to have his/her head examined. It's a camera for goodness sake. It won't make your life better and chances are, it won't even make your pictures that much better. I'd rather take the money and buy a plane ticket to someplace cool. In fact, that's exactly what I'm about to do later this week.

Of course, this is from a guy who used an F1 for about 30 years.

 

[Loswr]

Frankly, I think anyone who spends $3,000 on a camera body and isn't using it to earn a living ought to have his/her head examined.

I did. No abnormalities that I can see...

How many people get to take a self-portrait with a >1 million dollar camera? 8)


EXIF: GE Signa HDxt 1.5 Tesla MRI with
8-channel birdcage coil, T1-weighted image,
spin echo sequence, TE=10 milliseconds
(sort of like 1/100 s shutter speed)

Seriously, it's all about desire and budget. For many people, a $3K camera body is an extravagant purchase. For me, it's 10 hours of consulting work...

 

[iaind]

When it was released the 5D2 cost £2300 (Canon list price) approx$3600
Lowest UK price £1539 ($2450) assuming exchange rate of 1.60

A launch price of $3500 is not a bad estimate.
Hopefully the improvements will make it a FF 7d equivalent in terms of fps and focusing points.

1d4 comparison $7200/5700 is a bit steep for us poor enthusiasts

 

[K-amps]

Frankly, I think anyone who spends $3,000 on a camera body and isn't using it to earn a living ought to have his/her head examined.

I did. No abnormalities that I can see...

How many people get to take a self-portrait with a >1 million dollar camera? 8)


EXIF: GE Signa HDxt 1.5 Tesla MRI with
8-channel birdcage coil, T1-weighted image,
spin echo sequence, TE=10 milliseconds
(sort of like 1/100 s shutter speed)

Seriously, it's all about desire and budget. For many people, a $3K camera body is an extravagant purchase. For me, it's 10 hours of consulting work...

Neuro... the frontal cortex seems a bit atrophied... or in layman speak, a bit shriveled

 

[unfocused]

Seriously, it's all about desire and budget. For many people, a $3K camera body is an extravagant purchase. For me, it's 10 hours of consulting work...

I knew I shouldn't have majored in journalism.

Seriously, I respect your point. I appreciate that there are people like you working to keep the economy going. We certainly need it. As a matter of fact, in my day job I work in a legislative body for people who believe you are in a better position to judge how to spend your money than they are.

But from your posts, I know you are well-balanced and realistic. My point is simply that every minute spent obsessing over the next new toy (and I certainly enjoy my toys) and thinking that will make you a better photographer is a mistake. The tools we have available to us today are so vastly superior to what has available to most of the great photographers that we really don't have any good reasons to complain.

 

[te4o]

Neuro, how about income tax on the ten hours consultant work? This will make them 14 probably?
If I'd put my scan along you'd probably see just a huge archi-cerebellum extending to the coronary line :-[.
Anyway, I think for people having the 5d2/1Ds3 a steep price to upgrade needs a significant improvement for justification - so let the 5d3 be expensive...
For 1.6 APC users wanting to jump to FF any price below 3500 is acceptable given the projected time of usage. By the time it gets updated again, 3.5k will look like McDonalds change :-\

 

[Meh]

Neuro, how about income tax on the ten hours consultant work? This will make them 14 probably?
If I'd put my scan along you'd probably see just a huge archi-cerebellum extending to the coronary line :-[.
Anyway, I think for people having the 5d2/1Ds3 a steep price to upgrade needs a significant improvement for justification - so let the 5d3 be expensive...
For 1.6 APC users wanting to jump to FF any price below 3500 is acceptable given the projected time of usage. By the time it gets updated again, 3.5k will look like McDonalds change :-\

Other than getting into really big lenses or multiple bodies, etc. it's not completely unaffordable... camera gear has a fairly long life span and averaged out it's not that much more than other hobbies... anyone play golf for example?

 

[Loswr]

Neuro, how about income tax on the ten hours consultant work? This will make them 14 probably?

Fair enough. Call it 14.

Seriously, it's all about desire and budget. For many people, a $3K camera body is an extravagant purchase. For me, it's 10 hours of consulting work...

I knew I shouldn't have majored in journalism.

It's still all relative. I could say, "I knew I shouldn't have gotten a PhD in Neuroscience," when I visit the house of friends of ours - husband and wife, both anesthesiologists. I'm not actually sure how many rooms their house has, but one of them is a music conservatory with a grand piano and seating for 40 people. He shoots with a 1DsIII, by the way...

 

[JonJT]

All of you waiting for a 5DMK2 replacement, if it WAS $3500 would you still get it?

Absolutely not. But, I don't have to earn a living with my camera. And, I'm not waiting for a 5D III anyway. My 7D does everything I want and more. Compromises? Sure...but that's life.

Frankly, I think anyone who spends $3,000 on a camera body and isn't using it to earn a living ought to have his/her head examined. It's a camera for goodness sake. It won't make your life better and chances are, it won't even make your pictures that much better. I'd rather take the money and buy a plane ticket to someplace cool. In fact, that's exactly what I'm about to do later this week.

Of course, this is from a guy who used an F1 for about 30 years.

You could say this about any non-essential purchase. yet, people still spent 20-100 times more on things that that have no more utility than an alternative that is 1/20th the price. For such people, it's a matter of emotion and disposible income. I know a few people who have 5D/5DmkIIs but, who don't earn a dime from their cameras. If the 5DmkIII has the right features, I'll become one of those people.

Myself, and the people I know who have made such purchases budget properly and dont let themselves get introuble because of a preoccupation with the best photo equipment. In the end, we all die and none of this stuff goes with us. I see no reason to be overly frugal.

 

[rocketdesigner]

Frankly, I think anyone who spends $3,000 on a camera body and isn't using it to earn a living ought to have his/her head examined.

I did. No abnormalities that I can see...

How many people get to take a self-portrait with a >1 million dollar camera? 8)


EXIF: GE Signa HDxt 1.5 Tesla MRI with

You're not the only one .....

 

[epsiloneri]

For many people, a $3K camera body is an extravagant purchase. For me, it's 10 hours of consulting work...

Well I'm glad you don't charge for contributing to this forum... according to your stat page your time here would cost more than thirty pricy 5DmkII replacements