Asking for 5D III firmware improvements

[East Wind Photography]

1. AF focus speed with Speedlites

Read about this issue before but have not used my Speedlite so far. Just gave it a try now... 5D3 + 16-35L Mk II + 430EX II.

I switched of the light and started to focus in complete darkness with single AF point. At 35mm instant lock at different distances between 0.5 and 4m even with the most outside point. At 16mm the outside point is far away from the assist beam light so of course this does not work. But still instant lock with the center point. As long as the AF point is within the area illuminated by the assist beam I have no problems getting a fast focus lock.

+1 I dont see AF speed issue. Now if you disable the IR focus assist beam on the flash and try to focus with the 5D3 in low light. The AF will slow down but that happens with or without the flash and is a result of the camera using a different AF algorithm to get focus lock. Doesn't seem to matter whether the flash is used or not.

 

[DeckardSolo]

1. Ability to choose Auto ISO when using Custom Control SET->ISO. One approach would be press = auto iso, hold = choose iso (current functionality)

2. Custom Control for one-touch HDR on/off.

 

[Marsu42]

Customization what differentiates camera bodies like (6d/5d3), so I guess Canon will be hesitant to add any except on the 5d3.

Fyi: Many key-(re)mappings and ideas for lv can be easily implemented through Magic Lantern, you might be better off asking there then hoping for Canon. Ml currently cannot control non-lv af, and thus fore example cannot re-implement afma on the 60d (thanks, Canon!).

http://www.magiclantern.fm/forum/

 

[Bosman]

Don't forget Auto ISO in manual mode being able to exposure comp it like you normally could. So if you want to be 1/3 over no matter what the ISO chosen will adjust to make it possible. There really are many many things Canon could address with firmware to make this camera what it ought to be.

 

[Zlatko]

Don't forget Auto ISO in manual mode being able to exposure comp it like you normally could. So if you want to be 1/3 over no matter what the ISO chosen will adjust to make it possible. There really are many many things Canon could address with firmware to make this camera what it ought to be.

As far as I know, Canon has never offered exposure comp in manual mode on any EOS camera. Nikon and Leica do it, but I'm not a fan of that feature. I prefer manual to be pure manual, and exposure comp in manual goes against the idea of manual. If you're working in manual, it's so easy to adjust exposure up or down anyway and never make a mistake. As soon as you introduce the ability to exposure comp in manual, you introduce the chance of forgetting the exposure comp is on and screwing up all of your manual exposures. I use Auto ISO quite a lot in Av mode and then exposure comp comes in quite handy, but I don't see the advantage of using Auto ISO in Manual mode even if it had exposure comp.

 

[Marsu42]

but I don't see the advantage of using Auto ISO in Manual mode even if it had exposure comp.

I do: With a dynamic lighting scene you can pre-select your aperture (dof) and shutter speed (stop motion) while keeping the lowest possible noise level (= auto-iso). But with auto-iso you rely 100% on camera metering, and w/o expo-comp you cannot do anything about it even if you know that the camera has a tendency to over/underexpose or you know the scene is such the camera will get it wrong to one side.

 

[Zlatko]

but I don't see the advantage of using Auto ISO in Manual mode even if it had exposure comp.

I do: With a dynamic lighting scene you can pre-select your aperture (dof) and shutter speed (stop motion) while keeping the lowest possible noise level (= auto-iso). But with auto-iso you rely 100% on camera metering, and w/o expo-comp you cannot do anything about it even if you know that the camera has a tendency to over/underexpose or you know the scene is such the camera will get it wrong to one side.

OK, I can see using it in that way — when the light is changing and you want to keep a certain aperture and shutter speed. You can almost achieve the same goal by using Av mode and a minimum shutter speed setting for Auto ISO, along with any exposure comp that's needed. The only problem may be that the minimum shutter speed goes no higher than 1/250th, which is usually fine for me, but not fast enough for some sports and other action. Perhaps Canon can add higher minimum shutter speed options to Auto ISO. Ideally, exposure comp in Manual, if added by Canon, would be something you could enable or disable in a menu setting so people who like it the current way can keep it that way (and avoid accidental mis-setting).

 

[Marsu42]

You can almost achieve the same goal by using Av mode and a minimum shutter speed setting for Auto ISO, along with any exposure comp that's needed. The only problem may be that the minimum shutter speed goes no higher than 1/250th, which is usually fine for me, but not fast enough for some sports and other action. Perhaps Canon can add higher minimum shutter speed options to Auto ISO.

I know (and nearly wrote it myself), but Canon won't add it to the 6d/5d3 because faster shutter min speeds are a 1dx feature - which imho is ridiculously eclectic - and the feature is not available at all on other cameras like the 60d. And esp. on crop it really makes a difference retaining the lowest possible iso setting while having sufficient shutter speed.

 

[Louis]

The OP really need to start this thread over at the Canon forums and link back to this forum, I did that with the 5D3 focus assist beam problem and I got a reply from Canon

 

[DeckardSolo]

I went ahead and started a thread over at Canon:
http://forums.usa.canon.com/t5/EOS/Canon-5D-Mark-III-firmware-wishlist-feature-request/m-p/7081