Can the zoom fish-eye give rectilinear images on FF camera?

Status
Not open for further replies.

RGF

How you relate to the issue, is the issue.
Jul 13, 2012
2,817
37
22,151
Some one told me that the 8-15 fish-eye zoom can produce rectilinear images on a FF camera. Is this true?????


At all focal lengths or only at 15 mm? Or is a PS manipulation?
 
charlesa said:
Only at 15 mm

Incorrect.

The 8-15mm is a fisheye lens at all focal lengths. At 14-15mm on FF, it's a 'full frame fisheye' meaning the FoV fills the frame (you're getting an AoV of ~175°). At 8mm on FF, it's a 'circular fisheye' meaning a circular 180° AoV inset in the rectangle (black borders).

Focal-Lengths-and-Sensor-Sizes.jpg


If you want rectilinear from the 8-15mm fisheye, you must de-fish in post (at the cost of corner sharpness).

The widest rectilinear Canon lens is the 14mm prime, Sigma has a rectilinear zoom that goes to 12mm.
 
Upvote 0
neuroanatomist said:
charlesa said:
Only at 15 mm

Incorrect.

The 8-15mm is a fisheye lens at all focal lengths. At 14-15mm on FF, it's a 'full frame fisheye' meaning the FoV fills the frame (you're getting an AoV of ~175°). At 8mm on FF, it's a 'circular fisheye' meaning a circular 180° AoV inset in the rectangle (black borders).

Focal-Lengths-and-Sensor-Sizes.jpg


If you want rectilinear from the 8-15mm fisheye, you must de-fish in post (at the cost of corner sharpness).

The widest rectilinear Canon lens is the 14mm prime, Sigma has a rectilinear zoom that goes to 12mm.

Neuro

Great info as usual. Follow on question - what is the image quality of the sigma 12mm and how does it compare to the canon 14mm (which I have)
 
Upvote 0
RGF said:
Some one told me that the 8-15 fish-eye zoom can produce rectilinear images on a FF camera. Is this true?????


At all focal lengths or only at 15 mm? Or is a PS manipulation?

LR has a lens profile for the Canon 15mm f/2.8 fisheye, which can be used to defish images well for the 8-15 f/4. A defished 8-15 image at 15mm has a wider AOV than the EF 14 II rectilinear, so defishing does have at least one advantage. The corners and edges of a defished image do soften up as one would expect, but it's decent if you don't pixel peep.
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.