I want a 135mm 1.8 IS L

Status
Not open for further replies.
May 24, 2011
334
0
7,016
135mm_mini.jpg


Canon needs to make this lens, now.
 
@f/2, it'd have an 67.5mm front element and could use 77mm filters easily. @f/1.8, the 75mm max aperture would mean 82mm (or bigger) filters. So personally, I'd rather have the f/2 version. Which exists. Could you explain why the 1.8 is so important? Btw, I totally agree on the IS. A 100mm@f/1.8-sized - non-L - 135mm (with or without IS) would be great too, btw. Nicely inconspicuous.
 
Upvote 0
dr croubie said:
a99 + 135 f/1.8.
Full frame, 135mm f/1.8, Image Stabilised, 24 million lovely Exmor pixels, 14 bits of DR at ISO50, 10fps, beautiful Zeiss glass. What more could you want?
Nice lens, but look at the price of that Sony lens: $1,798. That is twice the price of the current Canon 135/2L. And it doesn't actually have image stabilization (you have to buy a Sony camera for that). Imagine how people will complain if Canon introduces a new 135mm lens at the Sony's price. The forums would be abuzz with new accusations of "greed" and how Canon keeps "screwing" their customers.
 
Upvote 0
Rat said:
@f/2, it'd have an 67.5mm front element and could use 77mm filters easily. @f/1.8, the 75mm max aperture would mean 82mm (or bigger) filters. So personally, I'd rather have the f/2 version. Which exists. Could you explain why the 1.8 is so important? Btw, I totally agree on the IS. A 100mm@f/1.8-sized - non-L - 135mm (with or without IS) would be great too, btw. Nicely inconspicuous.

The Sony/Zeiss uses 77mm filter, just sayin' :P
 
Upvote 0
Zlatko said:
dr croubie said:
a99 + 135 f/1.8.
Full frame, 135mm f/1.8, Image Stabilised, 24 million lovely Exmor pixels, 14 bits of DR at ISO50, 10fps, beautiful Zeiss glass. What more could you want?
Nice lens, but look at the price of that Sony lens: $1,798. That is twice the price of the current Canon 135/2L. And it doesn't actually have image stabilization (you have to buy a Sony camera for that). Imagine how people will complain if Canon introduces a new 135mm lens at the Sony's price. The forums would be abuzz with new accusations of "greed" and how Canon keeps "screwing" their customers.

... as opposed to what happens now: Canon releases IS lenses at exactly the price of the 20 year-old lenses that they replace, and forums are full of praise for Canon's wonderful cheap lenses and how much they love foregoing profit to keep customers happy?
 
Upvote 0
dr croubie said:
Zlatko said:
dr croubie said:
a99 + 135 f/1.8.
Full frame, 135mm f/1.8, Image Stabilised, 24 million lovely Exmor pixels, 14 bits of DR at ISO50, 10fps, beautiful Zeiss glass. What more could you want?
Nice lens, but look at the price of that Sony lens: $1,798. That is twice the price of the current Canon 135/2L. And it doesn't actually have image stabilization (you have to buy a Sony camera for that). Imagine how people will complain if Canon introduces a new 135mm lens at the Sony's price. The forums would be abuzz with new accusations of "greed" and how Canon keeps "screwing" their customers.

... as opposed to what happens now: Canon releases IS lenses at exactly the price of the 20 year-old lenses that they replace, and forums are full of praise for Canon's wonderful cheap lenses and how much they love foregoing profit to keep customers happy?
What I meant to say is that I don't agree with the complaints about "outrageous" pricing. The new, improved lenses come with a higher price, which is to be expected. Nothing wrong with that. I wouldn't be surprised if a new 135/1.8L IS were offered at the same price as the Sony/Zeiss 135/1.8.
 
Upvote 0
Ellen Schmidtee said:
Going on a tangent - someone mentioned on the forums a 135mm(?) lens with an aperture made from liquid(?) that would darken under electric current creating a soft edged hole and excellent bokeh.

Could anyone remind the lens' manufacturer & model?

That would be this one.
(although I'm not sure about the 'darkening under current', i'm not sure how the Sony works.
The 'darkening under current' thingy was actually a Canon Patent (that will probably never make it into a lens)
 
Upvote 0
dr croubie said:
Ellen Schmidtee said:
Going on a tangent - someone mentioned on the forums a 135mm(?) lens with an aperture made from liquid(?) that would darken under electric current creating a soft edged hole and excellent bokeh.

Could anyone remind the lens' manufacturer & model?

That would be this one.

Thanks!

dr croubie said:
(although I'm not sure about the 'darkening under current', i'm not sure how the Sony works.
The 'darkening under current' thingy was actually a Canon Patent (that will probably never make it into a lens)

Seems I mixed a few details from the thread.
 
Upvote 0
Nikon-135mm-f1.8-lens-patent.png


Just as an asside Nikon has a patent on one possible design for this exact lens:

http://nikonrumors.com/2012/03/09/nikon-135mm-f1-8-lens-patent.aspx/

This is actually a very interesting design because it has very high distortion, 2%, yet it is extremely sharp and has no CA whatsoever both in the APO sense and otherwise.

As long as someone is listening at Canon it shouldn't be especially challenging to make this lens.
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.