• The Canon Rumors Forum has officially been shut down as of July 10, 2026.

    All data will be deleted on September 16, 2026.

    the ad free experience will return by July 17, 2026.

Samyang XP 50mm f/1.2 lens review

Not sealed. No AF. Not truly internally focusing -- the front element does stay behind the filter ring at all times, but it does move front to back (like the 50L). It certainly is a path of ingress without a filter in place.

For the f/1.2 obsessed, why not get the 50L? On refurb, it's $950ish and you get sealing, AF and a much more compact design.

For the sharpness obsessed, surely get the Sigma 50 Art. Flaky AF still crushes no AF for general use.

Glad to see Samyang making moves, though.

- A
 
Upvote 0
ahsanford said:
Not sealed. No AF. Not truly internally focusing -- the front element does stay behind the filter ring at all times, but it does move front to back (like the 50L). It certainly is a path of ingress without a filter in place.

For the f/1.2 obsessed, why not get the 50L? On refurb, it's $950ish and you get sealing, AF and a much more compact design.

For the sharpness obsessed, surely get the Sigma 50 Art. Flaky AF still crushes no AF for general use.

Glad to see Samyang making moves, though.

- A

Thank you, I do appreciate your advice! But I am interested in astro, landscapes and wildflowers for this lens. I do wish that it was sealed and find it strange that it is not.

I can't argue about the comparative compactness of the 50L, but the reviews I've read indicate that it is soft wide open. That won't work for astro.

Surely Canon will soon deliver a 50mm with really good AF and that will be my second 50mm.
 
Upvote 0
I like this pickle jar; it's so big I think it has it's own gravity. It will be hard to misplace.

But seriously, this thing is almost as sharp wide open as my Milvus 100 wide open. I hope I get some clear air soon for astro. And focusing is a delight; a well-damped focus ring and a reasonable amount of throw.
 
Upvote 0