I can't compare to the Canon 14, but if you use it MF, the Zeiss will be a joy to use. Search CR for "Zeiss 15 vs Canon 14" and you get some opinions.RGF said:I have the canon 14 and would love to upgrade to the zeiss 15. Hard to justify the $1500 or so the upgrade would cost. Definitely would get a better lens but not sure if that much ($1500) better
Zeidora said:I can't compare to the Canon 14, but if you use it MF, the Zeiss will be a joy to use. Search CR for "Zeiss 15 vs Canon 14" and you get some opinions.RGF said:I have the canon 14 and would love to upgrade to the zeiss 15. Hard to justify the $1500 or so the upgrade would cost. Definitely would get a better lens but not sure if that much ($1500) better
www.focusingscreen.com has interchangeable screens for 5D3 available. The prototype 5Ds screen is on the way to me so will test and report later. The MF matt screen does not interfere with AF for your other lenses.TAF said:I've got the Zeiss 50mm f1.4, and it is by far my favorite lens for image quality. The optical formula results in images that look like they were taken with my Rollei TLR (color rendition, boku, and just overall).
But being MF (and my having a 5D3) makes it a bit more difficult to use than is desirable, so it doesn't get as much use as it should. I hope the 5D4 has interchangeable screens.
It was also reasonably priced as lenses go ($750 or so), which makes it a really good starting point to try out MF and see if you like it.
Zeidora said:www.focusingscreen.com has interchangeable screens for 5D3 available. The prototype 5Ds screen is on the way to me so will test and report later. The MF matt screen does not interfere with AF for your other lenses.TAF said:I've got the Zeiss 50mm f1.4, and it is by far my favorite lens for image quality. The optical formula results in images that look like they were taken with my Rollei TLR (color rendition, boku, and just overall).
But being MF (and my having a 5D3) makes it a bit more difficult to use than is desirable, so it doesn't get as much use as it should. I hope the 5D4 has interchangeable screens.
It was also reasonably priced as lenses go ($750 or so), which makes it a really good starting point to try out MF and see if you like it.
The lack of easy interchangeable screens like on 5D2 is a real annoyance on the newer 5D models. I hope Canon gets the memo.
Zeidora said:Just got the 5DsR-dedicated S-type screen from Deki @ focussingscreen.com. Haven't installed it yet.
It's not that difficult to switch the screen. You need a JIS screwdriver, forceps are supplied with screen.
Re split indicator and AF, not sure. As far as I recall, the AF sensor is not behind the focusing screen, but somewhere else. In that case it should not interfere with AF.
I am very interested in how it works. I bought a Zacuto Z-finder, but I can't say I am thrilled. I'm sure it is a good solution for video, but so so for narrow DOF stills.Zeidora said:Just got the 5DsR-dedicated S-type screen from Deki @ focussingscreen.com. Haven't installed it yet.
It's not that difficult to switch the screen. You need a JIS screwdriver, forceps are supplied with screen.
Re split indicator and AF, not sure. As far as I recall, the AF sensor is not behind the focusing screen, but somewhere else. In that case it should not interfere with AF.
Eldar said:I am very interested in how it works. I bought a Zacuto Z-finder, but I can't say I am thrilled. I'm sure it is a good solution for video, but so so for narrow DOF stills.Zeidora said:Just got the 5DsR-dedicated S-type screen from Deki @ focussingscreen.com. Haven't installed it yet.
It's not that difficult to switch the screen. You need a JIS screwdriver, forceps are supplied with screen.
Re split indicator and AF, not sure. As far as I recall, the AF sensor is not behind the focusing screen, but somewhere else. In that case it should not interfere with AF.
With the S-screen in my 1DX, I can get a fairly high hit-rate with f1.4 on both the 55 and 85 Otus. Does that work with the new screen from focusingscreen.com? At f4-5 you should be able to get fairly good results with the standard screen.Zeidora said:Eldar said:I am very interested in how it works. I bought a Zacuto Z-finder, but I can't say I am thrilled. I'm sure it is a good solution for video, but so so for narrow DOF stills.Zeidora said:Just got the 5DsR-dedicated S-type screen from Deki @ focussingscreen.com. Haven't installed it yet.
It's not that difficult to switch the screen. You need a JIS screwdriver, forceps are supplied with screen.
Re split indicator and AF, not sure. As far as I recall, the AF sensor is not behind the focusing screen, but somewhere else. In that case it should not interfere with AF.
The new screen has only a customized front tab (smaller than on 5D3 models), otherwise same as other S-type screens. I manually modified a 5D3 screen for my 5DsR and it works very well. For relatively open shooting with 180 macro (f/4-5) it is dead on. With that I mean the shiny lens of the lizard's eye is sharp, the protruding eye-rim is soft, the snout is blurry. Focus confirm also works just as expected. I usually don't shoot all open, and the largest opening I have is f/1.4 on the Otus 55.
Give it a try, much cheaper than the Zacuto finder.
Eldar said:With the S-screen in my 1DX, I can get a fairly high hit-rate with f1.4 on both the 55 and 85 Otus. Does that work with the new screen from focusingscreen.com? At f4-5 you should be able to get fairly good results with the standard screen.Zeidora said:Eldar said:I am very interested in how it works. I bought a Zacuto Z-finder, but I can't say I am thrilled. I'm sure it is a good solution for video, but so so for narrow DOF stills.Zeidora said:Just got the 5DsR-dedicated S-type screen from Deki @ focussingscreen.com. Haven't installed it yet.
It's not that difficult to switch the screen. You need a JIS screwdriver, forceps are supplied with screen.
Re split indicator and AF, not sure. As far as I recall, the AF sensor is not behind the focusing screen, but somewhere else. In that case it should not interfere with AF.
The new screen has only a customized front tab (smaller than on 5D3 models), otherwise same as other S-type screens. I manually modified a 5D3 screen for my 5DsR and it works very well. For relatively open shooting with 180 macro (f/4-5) it is dead on. With that I mean the shiny lens of the lizard's eye is sharp, the protruding eye-rim is soft, the snout is blurry. Focus confirm also works just as expected. I usually don't shoot all open, and the largest opening I have is f/1.4 on the Otus 55.
Give it a try, much cheaper than the Zacuto finder.
NWPhil said:Eldar said:With the S-screen in my 1DX, I can get a fairly high hit-rate with f1.4 on both the 55 and 85 Otus. Does that work with the new screen from focusingscreen.com? At f4-5 you should be able to get fairly good results with the standard screen.Zeidora said:Eldar said:I am not very fond of split prism focusing, having used it on my older FD cameras. I was also aware of the problem you are describing, so I have not tried it recently. I prefer the S-screens.Zeidora said:Just got the 5DsR-dedicated S-type screen from Deki @ focussingscreen.com. Haven't installed it yet.
It's not that difficult to switch the screen. You need a JIS screwdriver, forceps are supplied with screen.
Re split indicator and AF, not sure. As far as I recall, the AF sensor is not behind the focusing screen, but somewhere else. In that case it should not interfere with AF.
I am very interested in how it works. I bought a Zacuto Z-finder, but I can't say I am thrilled. I'm sure it is a good solution for video, but so so for narrow DOF stills.
The new screen has only a customized front tab (smaller than on 5D3 models), otherwise same as other S-type screens. I manually modified a 5D3 screen for my 5DsR and it works very well. For relatively open shooting with 180 macro (f/4-5) it is dead on. With that I mean the shiny lens of the lizard's eye is sharp, the protruding eye-rim is soft, the snout is blurry. Focus confirm also works just as expected. I usually don't shoot all open, and the largest opening I have is f/1.4 on the Otus 55.
Give it a try, much cheaper than the Zacuto finder.
ever tried the Ec-L screen? I find it better than the S but there are a few instances that interferes with focusing itself - the inside "panels" at the cross-split sometimes reflect too much light.
I wish Canon would have a setting to decrease the AF rectangle when a single one is used
The focusingscreen screen, as far as I know, is just a Canon S-type screen cut down to fit the 5D3 or 5Ds viewfinder. It is sent in an original Canon screen case. If the Canon S-type in your 1D works for you, the focusingscreen version should work for you as well.Eldar said:With the S-screen in my 1DX, I can get a fairly high hit-rate with f1.4 on both the 55 and 85 Otus. Does that work with the new screen from focusingscreen.com? At f4-5 you should be able to get fairly good results with the standard screen.