Nice review with some tips for settings
The bird is 1300 px wingtip to wingtip - I am surprised at the level of noise for an image of that size and colour. What iso were you using and how did you process it?I have to say, in my limited experience with this camera, between the smooth motion through the EVF, and the advanced AF tracking features, if you can't get good bird photos with the R5, that's not the fault of the camera, that's a "you" problem.
(Yes I know this is a pretty rare species, but I'll never give away my secret birding spots. Also this is a 1:1 crop, so don't get too excited if it seems a little noisy. I only had a 70-200 with me at the time, and I wasn't actually planning to take bird photos, just seeing what the camera would do.)
View attachment 192107
Again, what iso and was it from RAW?It was pretty badly underexposed to begin with. So yeah this was not under ideal conditions.
View attachment 192143
Yes it was RAW, at ISO 100. I did crank up the sharpening to about 80 in Adboe Camera Raw though, and I don't think hardly any noise reduction. I really don't think it's that bad, given that it's a crop down from this.Again, what iso and was it from RAW?
Here is something I posted a week or two ago in https://www.canonrumors.com/forum/threads/show-your-bird-portraits.1280/page-1067Yes it was RAW, at ISO 100. I did crank up the sharpening to about 80 in Adboe Camera Raw though, and I don't think hardly any noise reduction. I really don't think it's that bad, given that it's a crop down from this.
Ok, so what are you getting at with posting this?Here is something I posted a week or two ago in https://www.canonrumors.com/forum/threads/show-your-bird-portraits.1280/page-1067
I walked into a bird hide with my camera set at 1/3200s and iso320 for BIF but I saw a wren struggling against a closed window. I took a quick shot or two and rushed over to let it out rather than spend time resetting as it was struggling. I had to push through 5 stops from what looked like pitch black and was able to get something cropped a bit larger than yours. I routinely push through 2 stops.
That I am not impressed by the huge amount of noise you got pushing iso100 through a couple of stops. I would be very unhappy with that. You shouldn't see any noticeable noise from that exposure.Ok, so what are you getting at with posting this?
I guess I'm really not seeing the egregious amount of noise that you are in that photo. Maybe a little, but in a photo that is pretty monochromatic, I'm not too surprised by it.That I am not impressed by the huge amount of noise you got pushing iso100 through a couple of stops. I would be very unhappy with that. You shouldn't see any noticeable noise from that exposure.
In your opinion, is it now acceptably sharp? If so, then fine.I guess I'm really not seeing the egregious amount of noise that you are in that photo. Maybe a little, but in a photo that is pretty monochromatic, I'm not too surprised by it.
Here is the same photo just with the exposure and shadows raised to an acceptable level, with just what I think is the default level of noise reduction in camera raw, and without also tweaking the sharpness and clarity. Is this better?
View attachment 192155
Looks a little soft to be honest, which is why I boosted the sharpness/clarity to begin with. It was at f2.8 on the EF 70-200 2.8 ii.In your opinion, is it now acceptably sharp? If so, then fine.