Hi, I am having a hard time making a decision on which lens to buy: the existing 16-35 f/4L IS or the upcoming (?) 16-35 f/2.8 III. I am leaning towards the f/4 one as it fits my needs very well, I am just concerned about the autofocus performance difference between 2.8 and 4.0 maximum apertures.
I am currently looking at the following comparison of AF patterns: http://photo.stackexchange.com/questions/16399/what-apertures-are-required-to-enable-autofocus-including-cross-type-or-high-pr
For newer cameras, the only real differences between f/2.8 and f/4 would be in the high-precision sensors and dual cross-type points however, looking at the AF patterns, these points are typically in the image center. I do not happen to be using the center part very much for focusing so I am more concerned about the off center ones.
My questions are:
[list type=decimal]
[*]Am I missing any differences here? Even with the usual f/4 or f/5.6 sensitive points will the camera focus better with a f/2.8 lens rather than with a f/4 one (I wouldn't be surprised as there is more light available with a f/2.8 lens with maximum aperture, so the one that is used for focusing)
[*]Do you foresee that high-precision or dual cross-type points will be used closer to the edges in new cameras? The range seems to be growing (slowly) for the recents models, it's currently a column rather than one point.[/list]
I am mostly asking about the future direction (the camera is secondary to me really), but if this really matters, I will be using the lens with 7D (and 40D to some extent) now but I am planning on getting a 5D Mark IV (when it happens), will also consider 7D Mark III / 6D Mark II (if they happen).
AF precision is critical for me, it will be a deciding factor in the lens choice.
Thanks!
I am currently looking at the following comparison of AF patterns: http://photo.stackexchange.com/questions/16399/what-apertures-are-required-to-enable-autofocus-including-cross-type-or-high-pr
For newer cameras, the only real differences between f/2.8 and f/4 would be in the high-precision sensors and dual cross-type points however, looking at the AF patterns, these points are typically in the image center. I do not happen to be using the center part very much for focusing so I am more concerned about the off center ones.
My questions are:
[list type=decimal]
[*]Am I missing any differences here? Even with the usual f/4 or f/5.6 sensitive points will the camera focus better with a f/2.8 lens rather than with a f/4 one (I wouldn't be surprised as there is more light available with a f/2.8 lens with maximum aperture, so the one that is used for focusing)
[*]Do you foresee that high-precision or dual cross-type points will be used closer to the edges in new cameras? The range seems to be growing (slowly) for the recents models, it's currently a column rather than one point.[/list]
I am mostly asking about the future direction (the camera is secondary to me really), but if this really matters, I will be using the lens with 7D (and 40D to some extent) now but I am planning on getting a 5D Mark IV (when it happens), will also consider 7D Mark III / 6D Mark II (if they happen).
AF precision is critical for me, it will be a deciding factor in the lens choice.
Thanks!