Social experimant: I do not have enough smites soooo...

  • Thread starter Thread starter 5dmk.iii
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sort by date Sort by votes
5

5dmk.iii

Guest
#1
I am a new member and tried to help some people out an in no time I had 3 smites... and i did not flame anyone either. Some guys probably felt sorry for me and "equalized" my "karma... but I figure whats the worst karma I can get... so as a social experiment, I thought of isolating my posts to this one and see how many smite me for it...

Watch this clip... it's a bit old, but still funny and mirrors the feelings people have about me, the 5d.mkiii :P: Hitler rants about D3x
 
#3
AprilForever said:
Interesting! I get smitten all the time. Usually, you get smitten for stating your opinion, regardless of whether you flame or not. So, enjoy!
Click to expand...

There was a recent topic "should karma remain on the forum". My observation: Especially if your opinion is not "the most expensive red-ring and full frame Canon gear is always the most suitable for everyone" you're in for it :-) ... but there are enough helpful people around left to discuss with, so it doesn't matter.
 
Upvote 0
#4
Marsu42 said:
There was a recent topic "should karma remain on the forum". My observation: Especially if your opinion is not "the most expensive red-ring and full frame Canon gear is always the most suitable for everyone" you're in for it :-) ... but there are enough helpful people around left to discuss with, so it doesn't matter.
Click to expand...

True, best to grow some thick skin. On one thread where the OP wanted to RENT a midrange zoom for a APS-C body for a trip, people were suggesting the 24-70L because he could use it for full frame in the future. I pointed out that it was a rental situation and suggested that he should pick something else.
 
Upvote 0
#5
I have truly grown to despise the karma system. I know the smites are meaningless in any real sense, but it makes one feel unliked. What can I say, I'm an emotional cripple. At least I don't drink too much... yet.
 
Upvote 0
#6
There was a poll a few weeks ago that didn't stay up very long and had a small number of respondents. The [small] majority liked the system, but again -- the poll wasn't up for very long and the N was very very very small.

To me, it seems that there are those who vehemently hate it, and those who are mostly indifferent. Even a 30/70 split (hate/like) would indicate that it should be done away with. It seems to take away more than it adds.

Hopefully the mods will put it up for discussion again. Maybe we could just have an applaud system. That would accomplish the same goal (praising those most helpful) without the silly and often arbitrary negatives.
 
Upvote 0
#8
This is the only forum I am a member of that has the Karma system. Personally I think it is juvenile. If you follow a forum for more than fifteen seconds, you get to know who is full of crap and who is grand standing and who knows their stuff, without a Karma system.

For those who think it is a form of self regulation, look at other successful forums without the Karma system - they run just fine. On those forums, the general membership does not tolerate flamers running amok - they quickly get run outta town.

I think CR would be a better place with it. Just my two cents...

P.S.
5dmk.iii - I have seen this clip before and it is better then second time around! Applause to you!
 
Upvote 0
#10
I also don't think it teaches people a lesson - as it has been said by others in this post, you don't even know what you have been smited for - unless you just unleashed a total flam-o-gram rant on someone of course. Furthermore it is totally anonymous, which lacks any form of accountability.
 
Upvote 0
#11
briansquibb said:
Someone smites me all the time regardless of whether I comment or not
Click to expand...

They're just jealous of all your equipment :) I think it's gear envy.

As for the karma system, put me in the indifferent/apathetic category. Some of the most helpful, respectful, and experienced photogs on here have the most smites, which tells you that the karma system is a complete joke. Unfortunately, lots of people hit the smite button to restore their self-esteem whenever someone hurts their wittle feelings with an opinion that's different for their own.
 
Upvote 0
#12
Jamesy said:
I also don't think it teaches people a lesson - as it has been said by others in this post, you don't even know what you have been smited for - unless you just unleashed a total flam-o-gram rant on someone of course. Furthermore it is totally anonymous, which lacks any form of accountability.
Click to expand...
I suppose one could smite the moderators whenever they post as a form of protest, though I think they have access to information about smiters.
 
Upvote 0
#13
I don't even know what you all are even talking about. i guess i should poke around a bit. I've haven't really been to any forums on anything for something like 5yrs after i was pretty much kicked out of the minolta forum(tools!). I was surprised to find this place, pretty much by chance, and by chance whatever i first read looked interesting, so i lurk. -that video is great.
 
Upvote 0
#14
briansquibb said:
Someone smites me all the time regardless of whether I comment or not
Click to expand...

lol. I swear that someone logs on everyday just to smite you.

If you want to avoid smites, do not say anything other than "the 7D is the greatest camera ever made and nothing can surpass it". I gotta go. I think the 7D Gestapo are on to me......
 
Upvote 0
#17
That video busted my gut! ;D. Thanks for sharing. No smites from me, all applauds

Interesting subject, several weeks ago when there was a poll for keeping karma, I voted to keep it. Today I'd say pull it unless maybe you could see what post you got neg or pos karma for.

I have a few smites and honestly I couldn't tell you why. Read my posts. I think my posts are either helpful, valid questions, or non controversial remarks. Just remember, CR has a huge following, lots of folks, opinions, and personalities.

I'm convinced if you list your opinion and it differs from someone else, you will eventually get smitten. Pretty sure I got dinged for listing "No flip-out screen" on my 7D II wish list. Not losing any sleep over it ;)
 
Upvote 0
#18
Mt Spokane Photography said:
Thats the disgusting thing, people who abuse the system just for kicks
Click to expand...
I think people will have a hard time abusing the system because nobody seems to understands it - count me in. What does "smite" mean anyway? If it's the opposite reaction of "applaud" (which seems to be used like "agree"), than of course people who voice opinions will provoke "disagree" aka "smite".

Imho, there only should be a positive "good, informative post" rating - in combination with the post count, that would say everything that's needed.
 
Upvote 0
#20
RC said:
That video busted my gut! ;D. Thanks for sharing. No smites from me, all applauds

Interesting subject, several weeks ago when there was a poll for keeping karma, I voted to keep it. Today I'd say pull it unless maybe you could see what post you got neg or pos karma for.

I have a few smites and honestly I couldn't tell you why. Read my posts. I think my posts are either helpful, valid questions, or non controversial remarks. Just remember, CR has a huge following, lots of folks, opinions, and personalities.

I'm convinced if you list your opinion and it differs from someone else, you will eventually get smitten. Pretty sure I got dinged for listing "No flip-out screen" on my 7D II wish list. Not losing any sleep over it ;)
Click to expand...


Quoting my own post, 2 new smites in just minutes since I posted this. I rest my case.
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Home
Forums
Media
Menu