ecka said:
AlmostDecent said:
ecka said:
AlmostDecent said:
ecka said:
AlmostDecent said:
ecka said:
Try this one.
http://pliki.optyczne.pl/tam35/tam35_fot13.JPG
Obviously since the section of image is so small compared to the overall frame (1000 pixels of the 6000), one needs to reduce the fringe. Aside from that:
So now, do you agree that it is not a zero click solution? Sometimes it can be a real headache. Those are just a quick search samples, but there are situations when the CA and fringing is just too much and you have to paint it out of there, literally.
Perhaps zero click was a bit excessive, but hardly the Mission Impossible you painted. Even in your last request above, all I did was take my default setting, set the green to zero (down from +5), and lower the purple to +2 instead of +5. In your last example, you can't even see the fringing unless you are literally zoomed to 100%, and if you are planning on using an image where that is relevant, I would assume the rest of the post-processing will also be more than zero clicks as well. It literally took me a couple of seconds, so very far from a headache.
What you did is you didn't actually remove the CA and fringing

, while still affecting everything from pink to purple. OK, let's leave it there, I see you are too stubborn to admit anything

.
Funny I was going to say the same thing. i showed you your images perfectly cleaned, and proved not only it could be done, but easily. In not one instance did you show any issues with my results, other than to say you found them so unbelievably good, I could only be cheating.
You are wrong. Ignoring the problem doesn't make it go away. Your effortless method doesn't work on images with purple object in it, without making a mess.
It does, and I proved it. If you had a criticism of the corrected images I shared, by all means.
BTW, regarding the CA compared to rival lenses, quoting LensTip (for example):
"The Canon 2/35 IS had very similar results in this category but its maximum level was a bit higher." (i.e. worse)
"The Nikkor AF-S 1.8/35G fared worse practically at all aperture values"
"Once again the Sigma A 1.4/35 is the most serious rival of the Tamron – it had results of 0.03-0.06% which were only slightly better depending on the aperture value."
http://www.lenstip.com/455.5-Lens_review-Tamron_SP_35_mm_f_1.8_Di_VC_USD_Chromatic_and_spherical_aberration.html
http://www.lenstip.com/365.5-Lens_review-Canon_EF_35_mm_f_2_IS_USM_Chromatic_and_spherical_aberration.html