DPReview Interview with Chuck Westfall of Canon USA
- By V8Beast
- EOS Bodies
- 155 Replies
psolberg said:I'm glad to see wedding talk. I recall almost universal agreement as to why 36MP was worse of weddings in every respect because it was huge, not necessary, and didn't go to ISO 500K. I predicted the tunes would change as soon as canon went higher. I'm not saying you changed your view and I'm not applying this to you, but I'm amazed as to how suddenly 50MP is just right for weddings because they are canon MP. Many Photographers are so brand dishonest with their statements that it is sad to see how they flip 180 just on a logo. I was all along on board that 36 was never too much, and I'm still on board that 50 isn't too much either.
Your memory is a bit selective. Before it became en vogue to bash Canon's DR performance, tons of people were complaining that 22 megapixels wasn't enough right after the 5D3 was announced. Sure, the only reason why some fanboys made such statements is because they were envious of the D800's 36 megapixels, but there were also plenty of Canon shooters claiming they needed at least 40 megapixels to update their flickr pages. As a proud Nikon shooter, I'm sure you noticed some people in the Nikon camp converting from the "low-light, high ISO" religion to the "slow FPS, high megapixel" religion during the D700 - D800 model update
However IF it is indeed the case that the 5Ds offers no DR improvements, and that its video image quality is a step back from the 5DIII, I think clearly this camera wasn't ready but was rushed out to try to beat whatever it was Sony is working on. It feels that management came and saw the D800 announcement 2 years ago, and tasked the team to ship more MP ASAP, everything else be damned. So they did (it seems).
No disagreement here. Unless the 5Ds offers some improvement in IQ other than resolution, it's definitely seems like it was rushed to market. It won't be long until Sony releases its 50 megapixel sensors, at which point it won't be surprising at all if Nikon puts it an all-around superior body.
Upvote
0