Looking for backup camera body

[bdunbar79]

Well I would like to have a backup camera body, and I currently shoot with both the 5D Mark III and 1D Mark IV. There is someone that has offered me his 1Ds Mark III that was his backup body (he pre-ordered the 1D X) for $4000. It wasn't used much because his backup wasn't used much, maybe has 5-7k actuations. He did send it to Canon to have it refurbished, which it is. Well, I'm not sure it is worth it. I can get a 5D Mark II for 2k that I wouldn't use as much as my current cameras, but I've never even used a 1Ds series camera. Would it be woth it? What can the 1Ds III do that say, the 5D Mark III and II can't? Thanks for any input.

P.S. I can afford it but the issue is whether it is worth it or necessary. Ah maybe I should just sell my 1D Mark IV and get a 1D X

 

[STEMI_RN]

What kind of stuff do you shoot?

 

[bdunbar79]

In the summer and fall not too much sports, mostly landscape, buildings, and portraits. We usually do a big trip in the fall somewhere, such as Pennsylvania or New York, and shoot for 5 days. Winter and spring it's all sports, with minimal landscape and portraits. Now, god forbid I have to do senior pictures, which could be this fall. I really haven't enjoyed weddings too much either.

 

[STEMI_RN]

Certainly a decent price for the body, and I think it would work great as a backup. (specs seem to fit nicely between your two main bodies), but I don't know a lot of people who have 3 bodies (especially three of the top models) and use them regularly. I would go for it if the price really isn't an issue for you. But I also agree with the thought of selling your current body and upgrading to the 1dx. Tough call really.

 

[pwp]

There is someone that has offered me his 1Ds Mark III that was his backup body for $4000.

Rather than a 1Ds3 for $4000 I'd way prefer to see you with another 5D3 with BG-E11 for a couple of hundred dollars less. It's new and will have full warranty. The 1Ds3 does have the 1-Series handling advantages, but will lose out in a big way on IQ, AF and ISO. You know this already as you have a 5D3.

I've always liked working with two identical bodies. There is no mental shift required when you move from one to the other.

PW

 

[bdunbar79]

There is someone that has offered me his 1Ds Mark III that was his backup body for $4000.

Rather than a 1Ds3 for $4000 I'd way prefer to see you with another 5D3 with BG-E11 for a couple of hundred dollars less. It's new and will have full warranty. The 1Ds3 does have the 1-Series handling advantages, but will lose out in a big way on IQ, AF and ISO. You know this already as you have a 5D3.

I've always liked working with two identical bodies. There is no mental shift required when you move from one to the other.

PW

That makes way more sense. I was thinking the 5D Mark III was actually better than the 1Ds Mk III in that it is 5 years newer, higher ISO, Digic 5, etc. Thanks for the tip. I suppose too I could wait for the 1DX to be out awhile, but if I got a 1DX I'd definitely sell the 1D4. But a second 5D Mk III with grip sounds better really, because I really am pleased with the way the 5D Mk III is working out for me. Thanks guys.

 

[bdunbar79]

I think I will go for second 5D Mk III body with the battery grip. Instead of buying a 1D X then, because I'll have 2 Mk III's and still a 1D4, the money I saved for the 1DX will go towards a 200mm f/2L lens. Oh so looking forward to this! I think having two Mk III's will help immensely for weddings. Thanks for the advice.