Following a post on the bird thread I am prompted to suggest this.
A copy of the other response is below.
Hi Alan.
Quote from Alan, “it’s always good to receive constructive criticism, and there is not enough of it here.”
Quite a while ago I was thinking of suggesting a ‘critics corner,” I started on a set of rules for my proposal, my thought was that initially it would probably be one open thread, all subjects allowed and included.
Critique Corner.
Rules.
Please post here if you really would like constructive criticism.
Don’t post here if all you want is praise.
Don’t post here if you don’t like or want criticism.
“I think this picture is rubbish” and “nice shot” are not sufficient, replies should include the reason why you do or do not like the photo, composition, lighting etc are good reasons to criticise a shot, I don’t like cats or Cadillacs are not good reasons to criticise a shot.
What do you think, worth asking for?
Cheers, Graham.
A copy of the other response is below.
Hi Alan.
Quote from Alan, “it’s always good to receive constructive criticism, and there is not enough of it here.”
Quite a while ago I was thinking of suggesting a ‘critics corner,” I started on a set of rules for my proposal, my thought was that initially it would probably be one open thread, all subjects allowed and included.
Critique Corner.
Rules.
Please post here if you really would like constructive criticism.
Don’t post here if all you want is praise.
Don’t post here if you don’t like or want criticism.
“I think this picture is rubbish” and “nice shot” are not sufficient, replies should include the reason why you do or do not like the photo, composition, lighting etc are good reasons to criticise a shot, I don’t like cats or Cadillacs are not good reasons to criticise a shot.
What do you think, worth asking for?
Cheers, Graham.