RickSpringfield said:
With all of the discussion around the 5D Mark IV, I keep thinking ... 'What are the comparable cameras from other manufacturers?'. Because we can't really just compare the 5D Mark III against the 5D Mark IV and declare a victory right? We know the IV will be better ... of course ... because its a IV not a III. But once you look at the offerings from the other major brands its not as easy. Pre-5DS I think this would have been an easy question to answer ... but now trying to make a baseline comparison seems a bit harder. And who really is the intended audience for this camera?
Trying to understand what is it the 5D IV is intended to do best other than natively accept Canon glass. Is it Video, Events, Weddings? And if so ... what feature or features make this a more compelling option than say a 5DS, or Sony blah, or Nikon blah. Its seems like a 5DS and that new WiFi Adapter could get you most of the way there. Which in my mind makes the 5DS/R Mark II the Canon camera to watch.
Well, you do got a point and from what i read, it´s been dismissed the camera uses....It looks like everybody want a A7 SII, a 1Dx II, a 5dS R, and a Alexa in one single body! And of course, one body that costs only 3k! And worse than that, the comparisons that are made between cameras are just unrealistic! It´s nonsense to compare a 1Dx II with Sony bodys, it´s just nonsese! Like it´s nonsense that someone that just makes video and need a really high end camera for huge video assignments, to want to buy a 1Dx II or a 5D markIV just for video purposes and want everything in those cameras. C-log´s (wich i would also love, i confess, but i understand why it´s not there). 1Dx II is a workhorse! it´s a terrific camera for stills and deliver you huge possibilitys for video! Not perfect for video? Well, it´s not ment to be! It´s just like the 5D markIV!
According to the rumours, we are going to have a really beautiful camera there! Improved ISO noise (witch i don´t complain in 5DIII, but if it comes better, just great!!), among other great features can make a really good camera to work!
It´s just amazing the huge talk about what camera could bring or not to bring...and it´s understandable, we all need something else more! However, most of the talk disperses a lot. First of all, we do need to understand cameras and what they can deliver. If some cameras are good in somethings, others are good in other things.
I´ll give you an example:
If you are a professional wildlife and nature photographer and videographer, wich camera do you choose? A Sony A7RII and give a priviledge to video but just loose the still captures because af of Sony is pretty bad for wildlife? Or a 1Dx II that gives you the top of the market in stills, and also provides excelent video resolution? Well, the perfect thing should be to have the both! But even then....what lenses do you have for Sony to film wildlife? And if you have a 500mm from canon wich is really expensive, do you want to buy another tele from sony to the other camera? One tele to film, another to still? You put adaptors and loose AF? How can you film those crazy little birds that are so fast with a lens and camera that don´t get thems in focus?
So, what if you are a comercial videographer? Do you really need a 1Dx II to film? Or the Sony A7 SII is the way to go?
It´s just too personal choice!!!!
So guys, How can you tell that this Canon 5DmkIV is a bad camera, or that Canon is disappointing?? What are you asking? Everything? Its not realistic!
What i would love to see in 5DmkIV in improvements and don´t have (at least not konwn):
- 1080HD 120fps (althoug of course i understand why doesn´t have)
- bufffer improvement (one of the bad things of my 5DIII is buffer, just hope a good improvement in this one)
- retro-iluminated buttons - It´s just terrible to shoot in the dark and try to hit the right button.
- Improvement in autofocus - The AF in 5DIII isn´t bad, but it´s not also very good.
- improvement in DR (yes its quite discussed this point, and for me this is what canon should improve more. It´s not bad, but can be better.
Finally, if canon makes a camera that can put toghether every stuff from 1DxII, 5DmkIV, A7 RII, A7 SII, 5DS R, i will buy it!!! For sure!!!
Errgghh.....wait, wait, but only if it costs less than 3,5k!
Just to finalize....If you have a 5DIII, a 1dx, 1dxII, 5ds r and you can´t get the best of the results....well, it´s time to consider that the fault it is not in the equipment....