Anyone have any tips that work for speeding up focus lock in low light situations (in my case wedding receptions)? I was hopeful that the 1DX would lock focus faster than the 5DMk3 bit alas it doesn't seem to. I love the camera after a half dozen weddings with it, and about 15 with the Mk3, but the extremely slow time to lock is killing me. Both the 5D1 and 5D2 did WAY better, which boggles my mind! If there are AF configurations I can try to speed things up I am eager to learn. Thanks all!
Speeding up 1DX foc lock... Any tips?
- Thread starter mccallew
- Start date
- Status
mccallew said:
Sample problem Mate,
Wedding yesterday, was great till the reception. If anything using af assist on the 600EX made it slower to single shot. I tried one point as well as expansion and zoning with no luck - still took 2-3 sec to get a lock.
This was iso 3200, f7.1 1/125 with ettl flash.
Swapped over to a 5D2 and it was instant.
I'm not happy, I'm on my second 1DX and I am half considering grabbing a D4 after my experience playing with one today it's lowlight focus ability obliterates the 1DX (not as fast in good light unfortunately).
I did google search and found that we aren't the only ones: http://photography-on-the.net/forum/showthread.php?t=1219299&page=1&fb_source=message
Upvote
0
It's exceptionally frustrating. I've only used the 600s on the 1DX and Mk3, and agree, until The lights get turned way down it is best to leave the AF assist been off. How did canon botch this so bad, especially on the 5D, a camera seemingly built for weddings. Is it a hardware or software problem, you think? I loath to think about switching to Nikon D4, especially since their color seems all over the map and I'd need 2... Maybe 1DX Mk2 will resolve this crappy AF...
Upvote
0
R
Richard Lane
Guest
In my testing at home, the things that helped with low-light, low contrast AF with the 1DX were:
1) Use One Shot Mode and Avoid AI Servo
2) Use Manual Select Single Point or Manual Select AF Expansion and choose a higher contrast point on the person or clothing. Also Avoid Spot Af point.
3) Avoid letting the camera choose the Automatic AF Points, so also avoid Zone Area AF Points. The Automatic and Zone AF points choose the closest point to the lens and you need to choose the point with the highest contrast.
4) IR AF Assist with the 580 EXII helped a lot in my tests with the 1DX. I don't have the 600 to test.
5) Keep FPS at 10 or less if using High "H" FPS. It seemed to save about 1-2 seconds in One Shot Mode.
6) Manual Focus if all else fails.
7) Live View Mode, not too practical though.
Rich
1) Use One Shot Mode and Avoid AI Servo
2) Use Manual Select Single Point or Manual Select AF Expansion and choose a higher contrast point on the person or clothing. Also Avoid Spot Af point.
3) Avoid letting the camera choose the Automatic AF Points, so also avoid Zone Area AF Points. The Automatic and Zone AF points choose the closest point to the lens and you need to choose the point with the highest contrast.
4) IR AF Assist with the 580 EXII helped a lot in my tests with the 1DX. I don't have the 600 to test.
5) Keep FPS at 10 or less if using High "H" FPS. It seemed to save about 1-2 seconds in One Shot Mode.
6) Manual Focus if all else fails.
7) Live View Mode, not too practical though.
Rich
Upvote
0
Just for the record, this doesn't at all apply to all 1d x's... Mine locks just as easy in no contrast/no light as it does in bright high contrast light.
But it is concering that there are so many of them out there.
You ALL M U S T report this to Canon, unless, it will never get fixed.
Just took this shot in a dark kitchen, Ai Servo, 4 points surrounding, Case 1, 12fps, this is the only shot I took of it. Couldn't see anything in the VF, it lock as fast as the lens motor had reach the correct distance, no hunting at all.
Exif: f1,6 1/250s at iso 10.000
But it is concering that there are so many of them out there.
You ALL M U S T report this to Canon, unless, it will never get fixed.
Just took this shot in a dark kitchen, Ai Servo, 4 points surrounding, Case 1, 12fps, this is the only shot I took of it. Couldn't see anything in the VF, it lock as fast as the lens motor had reach the correct distance, no hunting at all.
Exif: f1,6 1/250s at iso 10.000
Upvote
0
R
Richard Lane
Guest
Viggo,
Thanks for posting the example, it looks successful!
It seems to happen when there is low light, low contrast, stationary or slow moving subjects, and/or when the subject is rather flat. When there is an edge included in the shot like on your coffee pot handle then that seems to make it easier.
On my test, I hung a charcoal gray towel over the shower curtain bar in the bathroom with the light off (ambient light only from the hallway), I stood inside the doorway and the 1Dx failed to lock AF on the center of the towel in AI Servo. The edge seems to create contrast for the AF to lock onto, even if the edge is the same color as the problem area. I would imagine that this would present a problem at a wedding with dark tuxedo's and low contrast dresses in low light.
If I aimed at a towel with stripes under the same light, then no problem.
If I aimed at the white shower curtain "Bar Only" (which is "narrow" and round), then it locked focus in AI Servo.
If I aimed the AF Point at the front of the white cabinet or wall, then AI Servo struggled.
If I aimed at the corner, or top, or bottom "edge" of the white cabinet, then it locked focus in AI Servo although slower than One Shot.
All of the test results improved in One Shot mode.
If you could test yours under these conditions that would be great!
Thanks,
Rich
Thanks for posting the example, it looks successful!
It seems to happen when there is low light, low contrast, stationary or slow moving subjects, and/or when the subject is rather flat. When there is an edge included in the shot like on your coffee pot handle then that seems to make it easier.
On my test, I hung a charcoal gray towel over the shower curtain bar in the bathroom with the light off (ambient light only from the hallway), I stood inside the doorway and the 1Dx failed to lock AF on the center of the towel in AI Servo. The edge seems to create contrast for the AF to lock onto, even if the edge is the same color as the problem area. I would imagine that this would present a problem at a wedding with dark tuxedo's and low contrast dresses in low light.
If I aimed at a towel with stripes under the same light, then no problem.
If I aimed at the white shower curtain "Bar Only" (which is "narrow" and round), then it locked focus in AI Servo.
If I aimed the AF Point at the front of the white cabinet or wall, then AI Servo struggled.
If I aimed at the corner, or top, or bottom "edge" of the white cabinet, then it locked focus in AI Servo although slower than One Shot.
All of the test results improved in One Shot mode.
If you could test yours under these conditions that would be great!
Thanks,
Rich
Upvote
0
In real low-light, I agree that it doesn't lock focus any faster than the 5D3 or 1D4. It's pretty subjectively doing so even in well-lit areas. I wouldn't personally state that one of the 1D X's major advantages is AF lock speed, because I guess I haven't really realized that yet. There are other major things I like.
Upvote
0
R
Richard Lane
Guest
No offense taken at all. The solid color gray towel in low light is only trying to "simulate" low contrast to reproduce the problem, so that we can create a workaround solution until hopefully a firmware update can help improve this situation.
The conditions weren't with no light, it was with low light. It even struggled at ISO 10000 with low contrast.
Personally, I don't usually shoot towels in my bathroom either, as I tend to shoot action or sports and those subjects are moving quickly and/or wearing jerseys with numbers on them creating contrast. I'm also shooting under lights, poor lights sometimes but still lights. It's certainly more than mood lighting at a wedding reception.
I'm just learning the limits of the camera myself and trying to help others out. I would also like to add that initially I found the MKIV performed similarly to the 1DX under these same low contrast, Servo conditions, however the more testing that I've done in conjunction with the above techniques, I would now give a slight edge to the 1DX.
Wedding photographers shoot low contrast, slow moving subjects, in low light, and there seems to be more than a few that are experiencing this problem, and additionally Canon adds black AF points to their pro camera to top things off. Some of them also like AI Servo for their dancing or action shots during the reception.
I as well as many others, have found some ways to improve focusing under these conditions and they're listed in my post above. Yes, you can aim for faces, but a lot of faces and skin have low contrast too, especially with dim overhead lighting.
You could also aim for a dark contrasting hairline on a person with lighter skin. Aiming for the suit/white shirt border may be another solution. What has more contrast, your nose or eye, or a white shirt underneath a black tuxedo?
Some photographers were using Automatic and Zone AF in AI Servo, and they won't have a chance with those settings under those conditions. Their previous cameras seemed to have less of a problem with this, however this is an entirely new AF System.
Now, if the photographer can move the points manually to a contrasting edge, or shoot in One Shot, then the problem is greatly improved. Aiming for a contrasting edge will also help even in AI Servo! Some Wedding Photographers are actually using their 5D2 for the reception, and other experienced photographers have contemplated switching to Nikon, so it's a real problem.
So, if you would like to see if you got lucky and your 1DX doesn't have this limitation, then you could simulate my test above, if not then no problem.
The conditions weren't with no light, it was with low light. It even struggled at ISO 10000 with low contrast.
Personally, I don't usually shoot towels in my bathroom either, as I tend to shoot action or sports and those subjects are moving quickly and/or wearing jerseys with numbers on them creating contrast. I'm also shooting under lights, poor lights sometimes but still lights. It's certainly more than mood lighting at a wedding reception.
I'm just learning the limits of the camera myself and trying to help others out. I would also like to add that initially I found the MKIV performed similarly to the 1DX under these same low contrast, Servo conditions, however the more testing that I've done in conjunction with the above techniques, I would now give a slight edge to the 1DX.
Wedding photographers shoot low contrast, slow moving subjects, in low light, and there seems to be more than a few that are experiencing this problem, and additionally Canon adds black AF points to their pro camera to top things off. Some of them also like AI Servo for their dancing or action shots during the reception.
I as well as many others, have found some ways to improve focusing under these conditions and they're listed in my post above. Yes, you can aim for faces, but a lot of faces and skin have low contrast too, especially with dim overhead lighting.
You could also aim for a dark contrasting hairline on a person with lighter skin. Aiming for the suit/white shirt border may be another solution. What has more contrast, your nose or eye, or a white shirt underneath a black tuxedo?
Some photographers were using Automatic and Zone AF in AI Servo, and they won't have a chance with those settings under those conditions. Their previous cameras seemed to have less of a problem with this, however this is an entirely new AF System.
Now, if the photographer can move the points manually to a contrasting edge, or shoot in One Shot, then the problem is greatly improved. Aiming for a contrasting edge will also help even in AI Servo! Some Wedding Photographers are actually using their 5D2 for the reception, and other experienced photographers have contemplated switching to Nikon, so it's a real problem.
So, if you would like to see if you got lucky and your 1DX doesn't have this limitation, then you could simulate my test above, if not then no problem.
Upvote
0
I have shot almost 20 weddings with the 5D3 this year and I used to have the same frustraiting problem. I agree there is a big problem and it should be addressed but in the meantime I have discovered a couple things that has made me almost forget there is a problem. First off a good lens is very necessary. I almost always use my 70-200 or 24L which both focus fast in difficult lighting. The 50L completely falls apart as does the 85L. The AF assist is of no help unless it is very dark. I have found focusing without the AF assist on my 70-200 to be fairly easy even in really low light. The 24L seems like it does a lot better with the AF assist. I have also discovered that the camera does actually focus fast but the red conframation blink is often delayed. I changed the settings that allow me to take the shot without a focus lock and I have found that 9 times out of 10 the initial split second focus is in perfect focus even without the red conframation blink. Hope this helps. I seriously think there is something wrong with the AF assist on the 600ex or a combination of the 600ex and 5D3. I hope the fix it.
Upvote
0
OK SO HOLD UP FOR A SECOND.
This isn't the Ai Servo bug/low light contrast bug
This is single shot lowlight - AF assisted - 1DX, taking 2-3 sec to lock a target in lowlight - NOT AI SERVO (absolute POS in lowlight so no point trying useless servo in those conditions)
I would assume the 5D3 would have the same issue - I can't isolate it down to the 600EX or the body as I don't have any 580II's anymore.
If you turn off the AF assist it focuses marginally faster - however a 5D2 and 7D kick the snot through the 1DX in the same reception situation.
For me I can't afford to wait 2-3 sec for each focus - that's a lot of: "Oh sorry just hold for 2 seconds, waiting for my camera to focus..."
I reported similar findings to canon over a month ago still waiting for response
I don't want to be selling off my gear but the 1DX is costing me moments - which is unacceptable to me, this is my second body (I handed back the last one after it completely locked up shooting with 600EX flash fill, 70-200 II in broad daylight - several times over 2 weddings, this body as yet hasn't done that as yet) and not sure if I can be bothered with a 3rd.
---
My gutt says hardware - the AF points are so small they are fantastic for hand-off of points however this would hinder the af acquisition in lowlight - notice the nikon variation, center af points are massive in comparison.
This isn't the Ai Servo bug/low light contrast bug
This is single shot lowlight - AF assisted - 1DX, taking 2-3 sec to lock a target in lowlight - NOT AI SERVO (absolute POS in lowlight so no point trying useless servo in those conditions)
I would assume the 5D3 would have the same issue - I can't isolate it down to the 600EX or the body as I don't have any 580II's anymore.
If you turn off the AF assist it focuses marginally faster - however a 5D2 and 7D kick the snot through the 1DX in the same reception situation.
For me I can't afford to wait 2-3 sec for each focus - that's a lot of: "Oh sorry just hold for 2 seconds, waiting for my camera to focus..."
I reported similar findings to canon over a month ago still waiting for response
I don't want to be selling off my gear but the 1DX is costing me moments - which is unacceptable to me, this is my second body (I handed back the last one after it completely locked up shooting with 600EX flash fill, 70-200 II in broad daylight - several times over 2 weddings, this body as yet hasn't done that as yet) and not sure if I can be bothered with a 3rd.
---
My gutt says hardware - the AF points are so small they are fantastic for hand-off of points however this would hinder the af acquisition in lowlight - notice the nikon variation, center af points are massive in comparison.
Upvote
0
During wedding receptions, my issues come during first dances/parent dances and later in the evening during reception dancing. Even people posing on the dance floor static, aimed at their faces in one shot mode with a 600ex-rt with AF assist on is slow as mud. The 5DMk1 and 5DMk2 blow both the1DX and 5DMk3 out of the water in this regard. It is super frustrating. Like one of the commenters above, I lose moments, trying to catch a couple before they turn, or a smile or look, they are more often gone before I ever get focus The silver lining, if there is one, is that I am becoming even better at anticipating those moments... I have to so that I have the 2-3 seconds to lock focus. Also, I typically am shooting a 70-200 f/2.8 IS II, 24-70 f/2.8 (I hate this lens, but like the focal range) or 16-35 f/2.8. I'd like more primes, but mine are 50 and 85 1.2, which are awesome for portrait work but junk at a reception. I would love for this to be something that can be fixed in firmware, but if it can't the 1DX and 5D3 are merely a stepping stones to hopefully better cameras that don't have such glaring and seemingly obvious flaws.
Upvote
0
So this suddenly has nothing to do with Ai and working better with 10 instead of 12 fps and all that? I find Ai so good I veryvery rarely need One Shot, and I'm seriously low light. I'm so sorry it has problems causing you to miss shots, but if it is with af assist and a brand new flash, I'm sure it's firmware.
2-3 seconds for focus to lock is ridiculous!!
In Ai it locks as fast as the lens motor can get there.
2-3 seconds for focus to lock is ridiculous!!
In Ai it locks as fast as the lens motor can get there.
Upvote
0
Viggo I can tell you exactly why that locked.
see the white lines in the middle of the frame, the reflections along the handle? The 1D gobbles that up and latches on - not kidding.
if it wasn't so white it would hunt.
Now this is dark:
1/13, f1.4, ISO 12800 - and as much as I hate to say it - the d4 didn't even remotely hesitate - locked on instantly and accurately. The 1DX on the other hand racked once and gave up - this is in single shot mode. 3D tracking on the d4 actually locked on where as the 1DX yet again racked and gave up.
Not without its flaws - apparently they haven't worked out that artificial fluros trick out the d4/d800 wb yet? Completely laughable but I'd take messed up wb in artificial light over not being able to focus personally. The shot here is me testing out the 70-200 VR II - how many different wb variations do you count lol!
see the white lines in the middle of the frame, the reflections along the handle? The 1D gobbles that up and latches on - not kidding.
if it wasn't so white it would hunt.
Now this is dark:
1/13, f1.4, ISO 12800 - and as much as I hate to say it - the d4 didn't even remotely hesitate - locked on instantly and accurately. The 1DX on the other hand racked once and gave up - this is in single shot mode. 3D tracking on the d4 actually locked on where as the 1DX yet again racked and gave up.
Not without its flaws - apparently they haven't worked out that artificial fluros trick out the d4/d800 wb yet? Completely laughable but I'd take messed up wb in artificial light over not being able to focus personally. The shot here is me testing out the 70-200 VR II - how many different wb variations do you count lol!
Upvote
0
So, did another test. laid down a brown pillow with the seam the only contrast in 12800 f1,4 1/100s light, and the 5d2 locks in Ai Servo and the 1d X does not.
So I take back my previous statement. (didn't find a problem in my real world testing) but clearly, the 5d2 focus fast and hits in lower light, it's a fact.
So Canon; here's a big fcuk you to you!!
Take what works and make it BETTER not worse...
So I take back my previous statement. (didn't find a problem in my real world testing) but clearly, the 5d2 focus fast and hits in lower light, it's a fact.
So Canon; here's a big fcuk you to you!!
Take what works and make it BETTER not worse...
Upvote
0
MKIIIphotographer said:5D2 focuses fast and hits in low light... :Viggo said:funny, my 5D2 never did either
I didn't say track, and unless you have tried both, spare me the comments.
I, as many others, have just testet, the Ai servo lock time and in what light, is way better on the 5d2 using center point than the 1d X. And I don't think it's funny, I think it's bullsh!t and goes show yet again what Canon knows about AF systems. They use about 20 times as many crosstype points and 5 dual-cross, and still it doesn't do any better than nikon or an old 5d2 which cost half.
For me this isn't a HUGE issue, but when in a situation like wedding-receptions and other low-light portrait-stuff, this is of great significance.
I wonder how the 1d X is for concerts compared.
Upvote
0
I’m finding forum entries like this one really worrying.
Reason if you can be bothered reading, not relevant to thread though:
The 5d3 ticks all the boxes for me and I’m building up my resources to afford this with kit lens. I’m never going to earn money with this camera so the cost is a big deal and I won’t be buying another one any time soon. The problem I’ve got is that almost the very first thing I’ll be using it for is a very important (personally) wedding reception next year and if pros are having problems then I’d likely be sunk. Canon (well these posts) sure aren’t making it an easy decision to buy at the moment. I’m wondering if I should forget any FF body until all this is sorted, get a 16-35 L and use it with my current 500D on center point & 430EXii? I’m assuming that a 24-105 on a crop would be too long. The good news is that I don’t have to make any commitment until next April at the latest but if I got the 16-35 that would be at least 7 months of fun.
Are there any pros/advanced users on the forum that disagree with these findings?
Do you think there is any chance of Canon responding to these issues?
Reason if you can be bothered reading, not relevant to thread though:
The 5d3 ticks all the boxes for me and I’m building up my resources to afford this with kit lens. I’m never going to earn money with this camera so the cost is a big deal and I won’t be buying another one any time soon. The problem I’ve got is that almost the very first thing I’ll be using it for is a very important (personally) wedding reception next year and if pros are having problems then I’d likely be sunk. Canon (well these posts) sure aren’t making it an easy decision to buy at the moment. I’m wondering if I should forget any FF body until all this is sorted, get a 16-35 L and use it with my current 500D on center point & 430EXii? I’m assuming that a 24-105 on a crop would be too long. The good news is that I don’t have to make any commitment until next April at the latest but if I got the 16-35 that would be at least 7 months of fun.
Are there any pros/advanced users on the forum that disagree with these findings?
Do you think there is any chance of Canon responding to these issues?
Upvote
0
Had the same frustrating problem in low light the other day... (Canon 24-70 at F2.8, 1/125, ISO 1000) Even with a SpeedlLite 600EX...
My 1D IV was super fast to focus. The 1DX takes too long. :-\
I was, though, using The 5 surrounding points... I switched to single Point next day but I haven't tested low light situations yet.
I agree with most of the comments. Can't let the camera decide. Just place the single focus point where you need it.
One problem I found with the focusing points is that if you are vertically shooting a single person, standing up, full body and filling most of the frame, the closest AF point is under the neck. Usually I try to focus on the eyes or face... Somehow some of the AF modes have different "reaches" Some are closer to the edges than others...
I'll keep researching.
Good luck to all!
My 1D IV was super fast to focus. The 1DX takes too long. :-\
I was, though, using The 5 surrounding points... I switched to single Point next day but I haven't tested low light situations yet.
I agree with most of the comments. Can't let the camera decide. Just place the single focus point where you need it.
One problem I found with the focusing points is that if you are vertically shooting a single person, standing up, full body and filling most of the frame, the closest AF point is under the neck. Usually I try to focus on the eyes or face... Somehow some of the AF modes have different "reaches" Some are closer to the edges than others...
I'll keep researching.
Good luck to all!
Upvote
0
- Status
