5D Split? 5D X & 5D Mark III [CR1]

[moreorless]

Re: 5D Split? 5D X & 5D Mark III [CR1]

OTOH look at the D3x and D3s, now the former has wayyy more MP but guess which has the much greater low ISO DR? Also the D3x that has wayyy more MP. So it's not so simple. If the 5D3 doesn't have a new readout technology then it could end up having 18MP and LESS low ISO DR, by a few stops even, than the D800. Hopefully that won't be the case, although the fact that marketing isn't already bragging about 2 stops better real and 3 stops better usable DR in RAW for low ISO makes you wonder a little.

Anyway just pointing out that it is not as simple as to say we need it to be low MP so we can get say great low ISO DR. What technology they use matter a lot more than the MP count.

I agree its more complex than that which is why I believe as its wrong to dismiss these stats(based on those grounds anyway) or to hold views such as "downsized higher resolution will always equal lower resolution on noise performance".

 

[Chuck Alaimo]

Re: 5D Split? 5D X & 5D Mark III [CR1]

but in my opinion most hobbits don't really need a 5DIII.

I agree, since there are no power receptacles in Middle-Earth, those halflings won't be able to recharge the Li-Ion batteries of their DLSRs. Although I suppose they can always ask Gandalf to call down a lightning strike... "You shall not charge!!!

LOL!!!!!

http://chuckalaimo.com/

 

[Loswr]

Re: 5D Split? 5D X & 5D Mark III [CR1]

You are right - hobbyists wont be going for the 5DIII - we will be aiming for the 1DX

+1.

Although, I have to say the rumored spec list does give me some pause - enough to wait and see what the 5DIII/X has to offer. I do hope they announce the new body before the 1D X is actually available, it will make for a less risky decision.

 

[Axilrod]

Re: 5D Split? 5D X & 5D Mark III [CR1]

Interesting tidbit from a rumor from June (before 1DX was announced)
"The 5D Mark III wouldn’t make an appearance on the scene until summer 2012. It will feature a modified version of the upcoming 1Ds Mark IV sensor."

Does this mean that at least one of the upcoming cameras will share a similar sensor to the 1DX?

 

[bigblue1ca]

Re: 5D Split? 5D X & 5D Mark III [CR1]

You are right - hobbyists wont be going for the 5DIII - we will be aiming for the 1DX

+1.

Although, I have to say the rumored spec list does give me some pause - enough to wait and see what the 5DIII/X has to offer. I do hope they announce the new body before the 1D X is actually available, it will make for a less risky decision.

+1

I've mentioned previously I'm in the same boat and waiting to see the 5DIII/X before pulling the trigger on the 1D X. However the more I see pictures, videos, and read all the Canon information on the 1D X, the more I feel this pulling urge to get the 1D X regardless of what the 5DIII/X turns out to be....lol. Plus even if the 5DIII/X is announced at the end of this month, if the 1D X is any example (which hopefully it isn't), it'll be a long while for concrete reviews and we might be lucky to see it commercially available by the fall?

This is worse than being a kid waiting for Christmas. It will certainly be nice to see some RAW images from the 1D X and more comprehensive reviews than wow that looks good on LCD screen at a trade show. Some real life examples of actions shots in low light at 6400/12800/25600 would be a great place to start along with a detailed account of how great the AF actually is.

 

[iaind]

Re: 5D Split? 5D X & 5D Mark III [CR1]

You are right - hobbyists wont be going for the 5DIII - we will be aiming for the 1DX

+1.

Although, I have to say the rumored spec list does give me some pause - enough to wait and see what the 5DIII/X has to offer. I do hope they announce the new body before the 1D X is actually available, it will make for a less risky decision.

Same here. Originally thought the 1Dx was out of my budget, so await specs and prices of 5DIII/X to finally decide. If Canon bring bodies in at anything over £3000 the 1DX may begin to look relatively cheap.

 

[JR]

Re: 5D Split? 5D X & 5D Mark III [CR1]

Most hobbyist talk about not needing a higher MP 5DIII but in my opinion most hobbits don't really need a 5DIII. I hate the fact that hobbyist feel that professional camera bodies should be dumbed down to fit their needs.

I guess I am a hobbyist as I dont get money for my photos.

Why should hobbyists get inferior kit? I get a lot of hassle from journeymen pros because I roll up with better kit than them - because it is their living and they need the kit to make money so they dont spend. Hobbyists like me keep the pressure on the manufacturers because we will spend our money - but only on the better kit.

You are right - hobbyists wont be going for the 5DIII - we will be aiming for the 1DX

+1 there too, I am a hobbyist, and I will be going for the 1DX for sure...

 

[BDD]

Re: 5D Split? 5D X & 5D Mark III [CR1]

1D-X vs 5D3/X. I would think this would depend on your needs (honestly). Are there features in the 1D-X that will not be available in either the 5D3/X?

For me, if the specs are accurate, then the 5D3 will be more than suitable for my needs. Being that I'm a hobbyist and not a working photographer. Though, if you can see yourself getting both versions of the upcoming 5D and won't mind lugging around the heft/bulk of the 1D-X...I say go for it!

If I were sticking with Nikon...then I would be spending more money for a D3s or D4. Given the choice I would opt for a FF camera the size of a D800 or 5D3/X. As I do plan on taking this camera on my travels as well as shooting locally.

 

[vuilang]

Re: 5D Split? 5D X & 5D Mark III [CR1]

I think the next camera would be named in different model. Such as 3d or so...

 

[briansquibb]

Re: 5D Split? 5D X & 5D Mark III [CR1]

1D-X vs 5D3/X. I would think this would depend on your needs (honestly). Are there features in the 1D-X that will not be available in either the 5D3/X?

Hobbyists have wants rather than needs. Hardest thing is getting the budget together to satisfy those needs

 

[max]

Re: 5D Split? 5D X & 5D Mark III [CR1]

This seemed to be spot on for the 5D III

 

[BDD]

Re: 5D Split? 5D X & 5D Mark III [CR1]

This seemed to be spot on for the 5D III

I'm just glad Canon didn't decide to go with a high MP camera to compete with the Nikon D800 (s). I think the latest specs are confirmed. And Canon will be delivering a 5D3 with better native ISO (100-25,800...expandable to 102,xxx). Better than I expected. Bettering the native ISO spec of the Nikon D3s/D4.

Will be interesting watching the live cast tonight.

One item to add to my "gift to self xmas list"...I think next week Apple will be announcing the iPad 3 (2nd gift to self). Then, later this year, the iPhone 5 (will they finally give us at least a 4.5" screen & 4G LTE support?). Great year for techies...